Reading With The Lights Out: Batman, The Terror In The Night
Posted By Kaitlin Tremblay on April 19, 2013
Welcome back to Reading With The Lights Out! For this week’s column, we’re going to veer off in a potentially unexpected direction. Rather than look at our traditional ghost and ghoul stories, I want to talk about how horror elements creep into non-genre works, because fear and terror isn’t reserved for just the monsters and zombies! With that being said, let me introduce our first specimen for this experiment: Batman!
Batman’s very costume design manifests the idea of terror, which plays on the fear of the unknown. Terror is about the anticipation, a psychological response to the knowledge that something could be out and it could very well be dangerous and wanting to rip your face off. This is what Batman is supposed to signify to the criminals he’s facing off against: an overwhelming scary presence from within the shadows. In this case, it’s a situation of using fear and horror to mete out justice and to keep Gotham safe. It works because primal terror of monsters and creatures that we cannot immediately rationalize paralyze us temporarily, throwing our mental balance off and leaving us open and vulnerable.
But that’s not to say Batman himself is the only horrific element of his titular run. Batman has a (mostly) terrifying cast of villains that Roger Corman or Vincent Price would be happy to base a grainy, campy film around. Take Scarecrow, whose salient advantage and attack is to instill an all-consuming fear in people, to which he can then manipulate or dispose of as he sees fit. Let’s not forget that scarecrows themselves are already a B-side monster staple. (Any one remember Scary Stories To Tell In The Dark? Remember this?) Joker is also an easy example here also, because coulrophobia (a phobia of clowns) is one of the top ten most common specific phobias (and it’s supposedly the third most common fear in Britain). And I mean, while The Calculator may not be the most bone-chilling foe you’ve ever encountered, but neither were sheep until Black Sheep (2006) came along, and introduced this hilariously unsettling abomination.
Let’s look at a specific arc to see how this works out narratively. Court of Owls is the best recent example because it has two integral conflicts: an external monstrous villain and an internal psychological fear that eats away at you from the inside out. The Court and Talons themselves are right in line with Batman’s already frightening roaster of villains. Greg Capullo’s art is the perfect mixture of realistic and stylized, lending the court a slightly exaggerated look that makes them uncanny, both familiar and unfamiliar at the same time. It’s this effect that establishes the court as something to be afraid of: we do not know what they’re capable of, let alone if they’re even human.

Image: Court of Owls
Apologies in advance, but for this next part I need to jump into slight spoiler-territory. While all these elements are present through most Batman arcs, the labyrinth scene in Court of Owls creates a deeper dynamic that extends beyond just the fear for survival. Batman being trapped in the court’s labyrinth elevates this arc to utter horror in the way it epitomizes Batman’s own internal conflict and psychological despair. It’s not just about him facing off against monstrous villains (because he’s Batman and we all know even Superman isn’t a match for him. Joking! Got ya!) While he’s stuck in the maze, the terror becomes about whether or not Batman will overcome his own fear, his own struggle, or if he will succumb and be lost to an overwhelming insanity forever.
These pages, with their glaring blood red and intentionally disorientating layouts, felt like an homage to Dario Argento’s 1977 bloody horror film Suspiria. Aside from the fact that both works, Suspiria and Court of Owls, use a stunning and arresting red, it’s not just a superficial similarity between the two. They both use the insanely intense red colour to evoke the same paranoid, nervous, terrified feelings, and deep psychological undoing. And it works, and it is incredible. It evokes a losing of self, a complete unraveling of psyche and strength, and becoming lost within the unshackled remnants of your mind. It’s this, Bruce’s own self-conscious paranoia and fears, that makes Batman stories so terrifying. Good horror hinges on a distrust of self and one’s own perceptions, knowledge, memories, and motives.
This is also why in Grant Morrison’s Arkham Asylum it is Dr. Arkham himself and his seriously damaged psyche that is the real terror. Arkham Asylum as a setting represents the fear of the loss of ourselves that is so prevalent in horror stories: we’re afraid that what we are confronted with is not real, and a lot of the times, our own personal fears are what scares us the most. It’s the fear of complete insanity. It’s why the use of Two-Face in the story is so poignant: he represents the oscillation between normal and insane, our controlled self and our potential for unfathomable darkness. But what’s truly terrifying is that we contain these facets within ourselves, but that they can manipulated, the way Two-Face has been reduced in Arkham Asylum. If what we know to be true isn’t and if we are not in control of ourselves, then anything is possible. And that “anything” usually turns out to be on par with Lovecraftian evils.

Image: Haunted Knight.
While I could list off your typical tropes (monsters/serial killer, haunted house — Arkham Asylum, anyone? –, unlikely hero etc), these aren’t just what makes a great horror story. What makes horror engaging is taking these elements and transforming them into a story that creeps into your brain, crawls under your skin, and makes you run to flick on the light in the middle of the night. They unsettle you, even just for a moment, and make you doubt everything you know about the way the world works and your own sanity. This is what Jeph Loeb and Tim Sale’s Batman arcs accomplish so effortlessly. The Long Halloween is terrifying because while the killer is following a predictable pattern, the motives are unknown and therefore makes protection and defense near impossible. Court of Owls shares the same paranoia and teetering on the edge of insanity that Haunted Knight does, as well.
The horror isn’t always born from the external tropes (although they help and they’re tropes for a reason), but from the internal struggle at trying to rationalize these tropes and our (in)ability to defend against them. It’s when we’re not sure that we can defend ourselves that the real terror settles in and grips you. It’s the details, folks. Good horror is always in the details. You can have a ludicrous villain or monster, as long as the psychological backbone is working to completely undermine your hold on reality. Once that’s lost, all that’s left is to scream and hope that black shape really is just a shadow in the corner of your room.
Comments