Posted By Shanna Kopcsik on June 18, 2013
From the moment I started the first in Scott Westerfeld’s Uglies trilogy, I absolutely had to keep reading. I am fascinated by futuristic and dystopian tales, and delved into the classics like Farhenheit 451, 1984, A Clockwork Orange and Earth Abides throughout my younger years. Uglies is a simpler story but still a fun and smooth read that captures attention and interest.
The Uglies story takes place in a futuristic but degenerating society, but in Westerfeld’s world, to be pretty is the goal and function of everyone’s lives and once citizens reach a certain age, plastic and brain surgery force superficial beauty, interests, thoughts and actions. Unique technology, machines to make living easier and more enjoyable than ever, and even a whole slang language that has been adapted by society as a whole make this universe a strange, but fun setting for the tale.
Tally Youngblood is our heroine through the trilogy and Uglies, as the first installment in the series, follows her as she prepares to become pretty. Tally is forced to face the truth that the world she is hoping to become a part of is not all that she had hoped and that there are real and dangerous consequences not only to becoming pretty but also in dissenting from that mindset. Her friend has no desire to become pretty and leaves the city, following legends of a rebellion and a way to have a choice. Tally gets caught up in a battle between the world of the pretties, and the “Special Circumstances” enforcement department who maintain order in Tally’s world with secret and absolute authority.
Tally’s challenges not only lie in facing the threat of the Special Circumstances team ruining her future, but also in facing her own inner demons. Will Tally overcome her trained perception and will to become pretty to help her friend or will she stay comfortable in her expectations of the world and let go of her budding individuality as well as her friend and their potential adventures?
I struggled reading Uglies at several points and while I did enjoy the book, and went on to read the remainder of the series, I could not completely ignore the flaws I felt from the story. The practice of plastic surgery on teenagers to “perfect” their outward appearance portrays a world ours could potentially devolve into. And while Uglies admonishes this idea through the rebellion that Tally joins, her personal issues with this are not truly explored.
For something so personal and relatable in today’s world, the idea of scrapping one’s perception of reality and what must be true, as well as turning away from judgments based on beauty and what someone should be, is minimized into a story about Tally choosing to stay with the rebels because she fancies the most handsome boy of the rebellion.
Of course, it wouldn’t be a young adult novel without a love triangle and easily solved emotional problems right? This is where I feel Westerfeld gets it wrong. With this story, there was great potential for actually addressing the issues brought up so blatantly in the world he creates. In his series, his characters cut themselves for the high of feeling and clarity they achieve with the action, yet the ideas of cutting and addiction, real issues for teenagers, are never addressed. Again, instead of delving into the character’s inner dilemmas, we are subjected to jealousy, questionable loyalty and personalities as superficial as the pretties themselves.
While the plot issues and lost potential for a truly powerful story are enough to have the reader rolling their eyes, the slang language will solidify that response. I remember that while reading Anthony Burgess’A Clockwork Orange in school, we had to define each odd slang word used. This was not difficult but was more work added into what was a great story otherwise. The Uglies series shares this eccentricity and leaves the reader with the choice to attempt to understand the slang and contexts or to gloss over the passages, just achieving a basic understanding out of laziness. I have to admit, I did both of these at different times through the whole series, though it did come more naturally after the significant repetition of phrases through the books.
Oddly enough, I did still enjoy Uglies and I do still recommend reading and enjoying it. The rest of the series I did not enjoy as much as this first installment, but knowing what I am getting into when starting a story often allows me to forgive certain points, even the glaring ones, and allows me to not be as distracted by them. I hope that this helps new readers too because when you allow yourself to let go of what you want Uglies to be, say and mean, a fun easy read shines through.
Uglies is a complex, if at times superficial, story wrapped up in literal analogies of how society could one day be if allowed a certain path in the future. Tally is a hero who wants desperately to go back to being normal, but whose choices have changed her life forever. For an easy summer read, or a guilty pleasure, Uglies will paint an unique picture of a possible science fiction future that will at least bring up, while not answering, questions about where our society is headed, how teens and adults handle change, holding beliefs, loyalty and the need to fit in with and be the same as the communities we participate in. As always, I love books that challenge my perceptions and Scott Westerfeld’s Uglies accomplishes this with flair, energy, drama and intrigue. Go read Uglies, then share your own insights as the story will undoubtedly highlight your perceptions and intrigue your brain.
Categories: Bookworms
Tags: 1984, A Clockwork Orange, Anthony Burgess, apoca, apocalyptic, dystopia, dystopian novels, end of the world, Exciting, fun, hover, plastic surgery, Pretties, Scott Westerfeld, Special Circumstances, Specials, summer book, summer read, superficial, Tally Youngblood, Uglies, Young Adult, young adult novel, young adult series
Comments